Consequential Decision-Making Under Pressure

A Qualitative Study of Educational Leaders

Dissertation

Published 2015

Consequential Decision-Making Under Pressure

A Qualitative Study of Educational Leaders

By: Dr. Kimberly Bonniksen

Research Area: Leadership Decision-Making

Abstract

A qualitative study of how educational leaders make high-stakes decisions that shape institutional outcomes and organizational direction.

Overview

This doctoral dissertation presents a qualitative study of how educational leaders make high-stakes decisions under pressure. Through in-depth interviews and case studies, Dr. Bonniksen explores the decision-making processes of school leaders facing consequential choices—decisions that significantly impact student outcomes, institutional culture, and organizational direction. The research identifies common patterns in how effective leaders approach complex decisions, manage uncertainty, involve stakeholders, and navigate the tension between urgency and deliberation. The findings provide valuable insights for leaders across sectors facing similar decision-making challenges.

Key Takeaways

1

Decision-making frameworks for high-stakes leadership choices

2

Managing uncertainty and incomplete information in critical decisions

3

Stakeholder engagement in consequential decision-making

4

Balancing urgency with deliberation in leadership decisions

5

Post-decision implementation and accountability strategies